![]() Background facts The recommendations are based on the teachers and students questionnaires that were collated during 2005-2007. The following results are the statistically most effective methods based on the teacher’s judgment of how successful their students were after completed module/course, i.e. the students’ achievement rate of the course objectives. Students’ questionnaires were issued in order to obtain a range of factual information and students’ perceptions. All 1125 students’ answers completed the perception of the students. Of the students taking part in the project 75% had extensive experience as a learner, 20% had substantial prior experience while only 5% had a small amount of experience or none at all. The factual questions were designed to facilitate analysis by level of study, age and gender. The other questions related to the students’ levels of former study experience, the relevance of the learning program to their job or future job, the effect of using combinations of teaching-learning methodology on the learning process and how effective they considered these methods to be. Basic level Teacher’s perspective:
![]() Computer-based learning, Individual training and Facilitated open learning The results indicates that even in the workshop based classes, teachers ought to experiment more often with computer-based learning, facilitated open learning and individual training but restrict lectures. Students’ perspective:
![]() Computer-based learning, Individual training and Mentoring consultancy Although seldom used, mentoring consultancy had the highest success rate, followed by computer-based learning and individual training. Even though these methods were rarely used, they were experienced as highly successful, more motivating and interesting by the students. To measure the student’s satisfaction with, and benefit from, the chosen methods, it’s very important to help the students how to recognize or state which methods that were used where and when. Learn more about Basic level >> The courses ranged from the more traditional work shop subjects to the more theoretical (Technical English and Design and Verification of Mechanical Elements). There were twelve teachers involved, four from Denmark, two from Sweden, three from the UK, two from Switzerland and one from Catalonia. Class sizes ranged from 12 to 29. All results and furthermore conclusions drawn at Basic level refer to In search of Excellence – developed teaching to improve learning. Conclusion and recomendation at Basic level
Advanced level Teacher’s perspective:
![]() Computer-based learning, Company based learning and Practical skills development A combination of computer-based learning, company based learning and practical skills development would achieve a high achievement of objectives. Furthermore, indicators show that lectures and individual training were successful, along with facilitated open learning. When computer-based learning was used to a high percentage of the teaching methodology, objective achievement was very good. This shows that computer-based learning has numerous positive applications. Students’ perspective:
![]() Lecture, Computer-based learning, Company based learning and Facilitated open learning According to the students, company based learning and facilitated open learning achieved the highest success rates. If the students were accustomed to lectures, asking them to be responsible for their own learning can pose difficulties at first, transferring from a teacher-directed view to a student-centred method of learning. However, changing the students’ views on teaching and learning will likely enhance and broaden their views on learning as well as their competence skills. Learn more about Basic level >> The courses ranged from Power Electro technical systems and Automated Production to the English A-course but were predominantly theoretical. The countries involved were Sweden, Switzerland, Catalonia and the UK engaging nine teachers and trainers, five from Sweden, two from Catalonia, one from Switzerland and one from the UK. Classes ranged in sizes from 6 to 34 students. All results and furthermore conclusions drawn at Advanced level refers to In search of excellence – developed teaching to improve learning. Conclusion and recomendation at Advanced level
University level Teacher’s perspective:
![]() Lecture, Computer-based learning and Company based learning Analysis of the results indicates that lectures, computer-based learning and company based learning were the most successful methods. Lecturing was most successful if restricted to 25% of the overall teaching process. Computer-based learning and company based learning were most successful when accounted for 25%-50%. The results presented for all levels of students supports the findings at University level that lectures were most successful when used for up to 27% of the time, practical skills development 16% and company based learning for 25%. Students’ perspective:
![]() Lecture, Individual training, Practical skills development and Mentoring consultancy University level students indicated little differences between the successes of the different teaching methods. Although they initially expressed a preference for traditional methods the introduction of computer based learning, practical skills development and other student centred methods increased their motivation and level of success. Mentoring consultancy was perceived as being the most successful. The use of computer simulation particularly multimedia learning programmes incorporating schematics, pictures, music and texts was also very popular with students. They also indicated that they were more highly motivated due to being involved in determining the learning process. Learn more about University level >> The countries involved at University level were the UK and Bulgaria involving a total of eight teachers and trainers. The study in the UK was centred on the delivery of a work based foundation degree and the course was at an equivalent level to the first two years of a traditional degree programme and comprised a broad range of engineering related subjects. The study in Bulgaria centred on a number of discrete subject based courses in physical chemistry, informatics, mine lighting and electrical/electronic engineering. All results and furthermore conclusions drawn at University level refer to In search of Excellence – developed teaching to improve learning. Conclusion and recomendation at Advanced level
Recommendations covering all levels
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||